Hopefully this explanation of the games ending will make it easier to understand. Place of death Mollys story, the first you play in What Remains of Edith Finch, is both one of the strangest and hardest to decipher in the game. Finally, after being down there for so long, Walter smashes down the wall and steps outside.only to step on some train tracks just as a train is coming. It was first announced in an on-stage trailer at the 2014 PlayStation Experience, as a title to be published by Santa Monica Studio,[5] with a subsequent trailer released prior to E3 2015. Walter seems to have been in the bunker since he was 16, as the first time you control him the calendar says "1968". Barbaras story is one of the best in Giant Sparrows game. This utilitarian space was later abandoned, even though the remaining Finches will have had to cross it to get to their part of the house for quite some time. What Remains of Edith Finch / Tear Jerker - TV Tropes Likely this is with Edie's coercion. THE HOUSE. Edith died during childbirth but the diary told her son about what happened to her family. It is a beautiful story that becomes even more touching with additional playthroughs. We get to play through her imaginings - her way of filling gaps in her knowledge, aided by her family's possessions. The story behind Marvel Snap's strangest card, Digital Foundry| Date of birth Walter Walter's room is accessed through the basement. Implied to have been killed in an earthquake somewhere in India on a rescue mission. In 2010, after struggling with substance abuse and mental illness, Lewis commits suicide at the age of 21. We hear heartbeats as Edith gives birth, her words appearing in what seems like cells floating in a blood vessel. Edie's mural of Walter for his memorial shrine. Sam and Kay get a divorce, and, at 33, whilst on a hunting trip with Dawn, Sam falls to his death after being bucked from a cliff by a deer. In Edith Finch, hoarding is as much a symptom of trauma as it signifies the wish to honour the history of a family who is most well-known for not being able to build much of a history at all. Milton Finch (The King) - Indicated to have died by the quote, "none of this will last for long". She particularly loves interactive storytelling and cuddling with her cats. [1][2], To link these mini-experiences, they had to come up with a framing device. Inspired by the story of Harry R. Truman, a man who had refused to leave his home prior to the eruption of Mount St. Helens, the team had envisioned a scenario that Edie would have also refused to leave her family home despite the threat of a nearby forest fire sometime in the 1980s. Christopher (great-grandson) Affiliation Finch Family Biographical information Marital status Divorced and remarried Date of birth April 25, 1950 Place of birth America Date of death June 16, 1983 Place of death Odin Finch National Park Information Gender Male Eye color Brown "Dawn, I promise, you'll never forget this weekend." What Remains of Edith Finch Walkthrough & Guide - GameSpot It is assumed that Walter felt guilty for his father's death, since the man was killed by a beam while he was building a dragon-shaped slide as a birthday present. Edith is visiting her family home, after many years away, to discover more about the deaths of her family members. They leave with Edie still at the house and they never see her again. He couldn't have been hit by a train, considering they live on a tiny island and those train tracks fall away into the *ocean. [1] Dallas credits suggestions made by Dino Patti of Playdead and Jenova Chen of thatgamecompany, following a playtest of the game, of inspiring the pregnancy and childbirth facets to close out the story after all the death that they had experienced. On the wall the Hollywood sign spells her name. [3], The team also recognized that from some of these mini-experiences they created, they wanted to leave them open-ended as to exactly what happened, following the convention of weird fiction to leave the player questioning if the mini-experiences they had played through were grounded in reality or not. We first hear of her pregnancy after leaning about Walters death. To Edie, longest surviving member of the family, everything seemed worth holding on to. (He dies in The Unfinished Swan, another Giant Sparrow game). Walter's story is incredibly sad. What Remains of Edith Finch plays with those established conventions to create a beautiful story that breaks your heart, while making you smile just as much. It's easy to imagine him as a quiet type who talks more to people online than to his family. They are sentimental knick-knacks with meaning that isn't immediately apparent. We know, already, that the game is told through the eyes of Edith, and that each of the vignettes are told through the eyes of each member of the family in some way. Exact cause of death unknown; likely to have died in the womb. Walter chose to live below ground and Sam is described as chasing death in the military. For more on What Remains of Edith Finch, including an explanation of every characters story, be sure to stick with us at Twinfinite. [27][28] EGMNow ranked the game at #25 in their list of the 25 Best Games of 2017,[29] while Polygon ranked it 13th on their list of the 50 best games of 2017. The image fades to someone reading her journal, and that person takes flowers and the diary to Ediths grave back at the Finch house. Walter Finch | What Remains of Edith Finch Wiki | Fandom Either scenario seems equally as likely based on the information the game presents us with, because of some impressively restrained and careful writing, and that type of care is ubiquitous throughout the entirety of What Remains of Edith Finch. That is until Edith realizes that she is pregnant. He climbs through and slowly walks through the mouth of the tunnel, which leads outside. it needs to eat people. We have plenty of evidence to deduce what most likely happened to them, but theres no way to know for sure. As he bends down at his coronation, his head is taken off by a guillotine, representing the machine in the cannery. As he thought, the only way to be crowned and live his life as his imagination intended would be to end the real world Lewis. If you ask me, the context clues seem to imply that her boyfriend killed her after their argument, and although its an unsubstantiated answer, all the pieces are there. Home PC What Remains of Edith Finch: Story and Ending Explained. However, Edith wants to ensure that her child hears about the fate of their family so she writes down everything in her journal once she reaches what used to be her room. Stardew Valley 7. [2], What Remains of Edith Finch received "generally positive" reviews across Windows, PlayStation 4, and Nintendo Switch platforms, while the Xbox One version received "universal acclaim", according to review aggregator Metacritic. Edie, however, refuses to go, and, after a heated argument, Dawn and Edith flee the house without her, leaving most of their possessions behind. We hear heartbeats as Edith gives birth, her words appearing in what seems like cells floating in a blood vessel. Sam and Dawn (Ediths mother) go on a camping trip and hunt a deer in the mountains. Some things are small. She says, maybe we believed so much in the family curse we made it real, which is how Dawn felt about it the day they left. To The Moon 9. She returns to her room where she is writing about what has happened to her while the monster waits for her under her bed. As Edith, we return to the family home, where the Finches had lived for more than a century after their first house sank just off the shore after they emigrated from Europe. The sadness of the story comes from the fact that Ediths mother chose to never share it with her daughter. Wow, really interesting theory! This led him to erect a bunker underneath the house, wherein he resided for over thirty years of his life. The tracks appear to have fallen away after he died, if you go right to where they end and look to the right of the cliff you can see the remains of the tracks on the other side. According to Lewis his imagination was as important as his body in the real world, and he left like it was somewhere he belonged. What Remains of Edith Finch's family curse is ambiguity done right She therefore decides that her and Edith should leave Edie and the curse behind with the house, even if Edie insists that they cannot run away from it. The story of his death is told through a series of images, narrated by Edith, that tell of how Odin left Europe to escape the family curse when his house wrecked off the coast of Washington, drowning him in the process. Her final moments are shared through a comic book, with perfectly matching creepy music and narration. The story, told through a letter written by Walter, portrays an earthquake like shaking that he calls a monster. Milton managed to create a family and legacy completely independent from the curse. Still, as a spooky, logical evolution of the Gone Homes and Firewatches of the world, with an impressive short-story style to boot, What Remains of Edith Finch is ultimately worth your time if its premise grabs you. If you havent played it yet, go do yourself a favor and take care of that, and maybe come back to this one later. Dallas had Russo try to create a soundtrack similar to the theme from John Carpenter's Halloween. He met a princess, built cities in his name, and was being crowned King of the land, yet he continued to live in the real world. At 10 years old, Molly dies after ingesting fluoridated toothpaste and holly berries; at 16, Barbara is murdered during a home invasion or implied domestic dispute; at 11, Calvin falls to his death after swinging off the edge of a cliff; at 49, Edie's husband Sven dies during a construction accident at the house; and, at 53, after having spent 30 years living as a recluse in a bunker beneath the house and traumatized at witnessing Barbara's death, Walter is hit by a train after stepping outside for the first time since. Affiliation Returning to the house, Edith discovers for herself the stories of her family's unique history, documenting her own thoughts and experiences in her journal. Hopefully this explanation of the game's ending will make it easier to understand. Either killed by fans or a serial killer. The Death Of Walter Finch | What Remains Of Edith Finch | Part 4 The whole walter story is one of the most implausible things about the game. The warning signs were there: all other Finches who got to spend significant portions of their early lives with a sibling before witnessing their deaths made drastic choices. Lewis' room does not. Sam Finch | What Remains of Edith Finch Wiki | Fandom Some of the other stories, though, have more ambiguous endings. Milton Finch (The King) - Indicated to have died by the quote, "none of this will last for long". Seven years later, Dawn succumbs to an undisclosed illness, and 17-year-old Edith inherits the property. joetry 6 yr. ago Just completed the game and really liked it. Thank you for sharing. Barbara's room, however, is a startling example of how unhappiness can spread quickly when a room reflects a part of your self-definition that you need to let go of. Walters story is incredibly sad. [2], The game had been in development since at least 2013, when Giant Sparrow partnered with Sony Computer Entertainment. Filed under Please enable JavaScript to see comments. After Lewis death, Dawn decided to get Edith away from Edie and the curse that had taken over the Finch household, but she didnt tell Edie until the night they left. The game centers on the character of Edith, a sole member of the Finch family who return to her family's house in Orcas Island to learn about her family "curse", that causes all but one member of each generation to die in unusual ways. If Walter died in 1968, who writes his letter in 2005? At Walter's time the train was working, so there must have been a bridge. [26] The same website also gave it the award of "Best Adventure Game" in their Best of 2017 Awards, and of "Best Narrative" and "Adventure Game of the Year" in their 2017 Adventure Game of the Year Awards. - 1977: Dawn, as an emotional 11-year old dealing with a new baby and potentially-divorcing parents, drowns Gregory while Kay is distracted. Sams story is one of the most simple in the game. They are both taking photos, through which the story is told, to document the trip but as Sam goes up a hill to attend to a deer Dawn has shot, the animal wriggles and knocks him off the side of a cliff. The story that Giant Sparrow has created for What Remains of Edith Finch is simple, but beautifully told. Every story told in What Remains of Edith Finch is interesting but Milton's is one of the most due to the obvious ties to The Unfinished Swan. If you havent played the whole of What Remains of Edith Finch, I would recommend playing it and returning when you have finished. He was a young man that had been affected deeply by the death of his family and the curse that was becoming all too real for him. [1] They did not want to make a horror game, where their purpose would be to intentionally scare the player, but wanted to borrow concepts common in the horror genre, such as Lovecraftian elements. Explanations are left in plain sight, but not over-explained to the point that they leave us without any room to question things. Firewatch, Persona 5, Witcher 3, Inside, What Remains Of Edith Finch, Breath Of The Wild, RE7, Cuphead, Super Mario Odyssey, Little Nightmares, Red Dead 2, Spider-Man . I assumed that the rumbling was the cliffside crumbling over time which eventually lead to the destruction of the railway. Ediths great-grandmother Edie is a staunch believer in the curse she spoke about it her whole life. :). Star Wars Jedi: Survivor's ray tracing impresses on PS5 - but also causes the biggest performance issues, Feature| "[23], Eurogamer ranked the game second on their list of the "Top 50 Games of 2017",[24] while GamesRadar+ ranked it fifth on their list of the 25 Best Games of 2017. [2] The team struggled on the diver idea until Dallas came up with the idea of a shark falling into a forest with a child uttering the line "and suddenly I was a shark", which sparked the idea of moving into more strange and unnatural scenarios; this specific one would eventually become the mini-experience for Molly, who died after eating poisonous holly berries and whose bedroom is the first the player explores in the game. "[20], Josh Harmon of EGMNow awarded it 7/10, stating that Edith Finch is "a brilliant accomplishment. After the disappearance of his brother Milton, Lewis began to shut himself off from the world and he was persuaded to see a therapist due to his substance abuse. I've just 'completed' Walter's story so the whole question is very fresh in my mind. The shrines and the rooms overall exemplify the great pitfall of instrumental materialism, which is how easily it can lead to hoarding. He told a different story to his son and left behind something hopeful instead of a curse. Sam marries a woman named Kay Carlyle, and they have three children: Dawn, Gus, and Gregory. Gus is flying a kite over the shore, away from the celebrations, when a storm rolls in and chairs and debris begin to be picked up by Gus kite as he tells the poem in the sky. Some other theories includes the suggestion that it was a fever dream and she died in her sleep, or that she went looking for food outside her window and fell to her death. This includes the door to Edie's own bedroom, oddly enough. Edith's narration guides the player, providing commentary on her own thoughts, experiences, and relations to each character; and therefore provides exposition and nuance relating to many of the semi-self-contained sequences in the game. This was ultimately trimmed down to showing Walter going through the same routine each day, eating peaches from a can, until one day he decides to escape. Gus Finch - Either drowned in a storm or crushed by tent equipment. Originally, once in the bunker, Walter would have experienced still people that moved when he looked away, similar to Doctor Who's Weeping Angels or The Prisoner, and then would imagine himself living on a model trainset where an invisible hand would move pieces around on the set. Since he had been underground for such a long time when he started leaving the tunnel he was blinded and unknowingly stepped off into open air when he thought he'd be stepping onto solid ground. His mother, Kay, is distracted by the phone after she empties the tub of water and Gregory manages to fill it up again. The performances are stellar, especially that of Valerie Rose Lohman as the titular role, the art is beautiful, and the game revolutionized narrative design on multiple occasions. It begins to look almost like the bark of a tree; something that has an order to it, but its too chaotic for us to be able to follow. The sternly worded house rules next to the list of chores tell us of Sam's fear of losing his children as well as his dedication to discipline. If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. The Joy of Edith Finch's hidden stories | Rock Paper Shotgun A terrifying new Edith Finch theory [Spoilers] :: What Remains of Edith She begins to get better but, as many cancer patients do, the sickness returns and she dies, leaving Edith on her own as the sole surviving member of the Finch family. It just destroyed since Walters death. Horizon Forbidden West: Burning Shores is a visual masterclass. Barbara Finch (br.b.r fnt | Baarbru Finch) was the secondborn and the second daughter of Sven and Edie, Barbara died the day of her 16th birthday. You play as Edith Finch and the perspective is first-person. Place of birth Lewis story is the most upsetting of all along Ediths journey but it is presented and told perfectly. My guess is they collapsed when the earthquake happened that Edie mentions. Walter probably didn't know that the rumbling he heard each morning was a train. Get the day's most talked about stories straight to your inbox. Various narrative-related objects including books, clutter, and decorations provide Edith this opportunity; which is framed as the vocalization of Edith's own writings in her journal revealed chronologically as she makes her way through the house. It might just destroyed the bridge. Sam's story runs through the Finch house like a red thread. While Miltons death is one of the most ambiguous tales in What Remains of Edith Finch, one of the developers at Giant Sparrow has shed some light on his connection to The Unfinished Swan, the studios first game. You have to take every story with a grain of salt, some easier to decipher, others less so. The player plays as Walter, who is seated in a chair in front of a calendar, a clock, and a can of peaches. This is either the behavior of a deeply troubled but benign woman, or one who is actively harming her own family in order to make herself feel better. They are forbidden from playing outside without permission or answering the door to strangers, and it's of equal importance to make no messes after dark, finish chores in a timely manner and respect each other. The wind picked up and he managed to do it but as he swung round he was flung from the seat towards the ocean and into the rocks below. The tracks curve around the side of the cliff to your right as you face the part where they're broken. Knocked off a cliff by a deer that was shot by Dawn. Drowned while attempting to sail his house across the ocean due to strong waves. The Death Of Walter Finch | What Remains Of Edith Finch | Part 4 Ifrit Overdrive 1.17K subscribers Subscribe 137 views 4 years ago Carrying on with this curious tale of death and. What Remains of Edith Finch is a narrative-focused walking simulator. Walter had been underground for a long time so he didn't know the railway had collapsed. She is clearly speaking to her son/daughter as she climbs towards Sams room. A terrifying new Edith Finch theory [Spoilers]. Instead of moving out, the house turned into an architectural impossibility in order to accommodate new family members as well as the old ones, making the coexistence of happy and sad memories the theme of the whole Finch family. Gus story is told through a poem written by Dawn, who is Ediths mother, and Gus sister. Look at Walter, for example maybe he was just an eccentric old man, so afraid of the curse that he locked himself away, drove himself mad in isolation, and broke his way out in a frenzied state of unconscious mania. Walter was traumatized as a child by his older sister Barbara's death, which led him to an extreme fear of the family curse. He was hit by the oncoming train, which was presumably late, and probably didn't hear it coming because he was so engrossed in the scenery. The only constants are that each is played from a first-person perspective and that each story ends with that family member's death. Maybe, then, Milton did really draw himself into another world, never to be seen by the Finches again. It might be a misdirection, but Edith would have recognize her mother's and great grandmother's writing. Climbing through, he goes down a ladder and over to a brick wall at the end of a tunnel. The player character takes a ferry to Orcas Island, Washington carrying the journal of Edith Finch. What Remains of Edith Finch: Story and Ending Explained - Twinfinite (He dies in The Unfinished Swan, another Giant Sparrow game). Maybe Sam wouldnt have died if she had taught him to be more careful. Players make progress by interacting with these shrines and experiencing vignettes of the relative's death. Odin Finch - While attempting to sail his house across the ocean he ended up sinking. You can try and turn on the light at the right of the . Now desperate, Dawn decides they must all leave the house. [30], The game won the award for "Best Story" in PC Gamer's 2017 Game of the Year Awards,[31] and was nominated for "Game of the Year". August 26, 1952[1] The therapist tells of how he began to live his life according the other world in his imagination. [32] It was also nominated for "Best Xbox One Game" in Destructoid's Game of the Year Awards 2017;[33] for "Best Adventure Game" and "Best Story" in IGN's Best of 2017 Awards;[34][35] and for "Best Moment or Sequence" (Cannery Sequence) in Giant Bomb's 2017 Game of the Year Awards.[36]. [1] The game initially was based on this scuba diving approach, but this created a number of problems with conveying narrative. In 1937, in an effort to escape the curse after the death of his wife Ingeborg and newborn son Johann, Edith's great-great-grandfather Odin Finch emigrates from Norway to the United States. What Remains of Edith Finch tells a fascinating story but some tales and the ending are quite ambiguous. All rights reserved. [2][7] Annapurna relaxed some of the deadlines that Sony had originally had for the title, allowing Giant Sparrow to keep and refine some of the more significant mini-experiences they created and would have otherwise had to cut under a tighter schedule. What Remains of Edith Finch tells a fascinating story but some tales and the ending are quite ambiguous. The "What Really Happened to Barbara?" Question Barbara Finch - Presumably tripped on her rollerskate or murdered by her boyfriend. "Edith Finch" redirects here. When Barbara's story ends,. What Remains of Edith Finch: Ending Explained - Twinfinite No part of this website or its content may be reproduced without the copyright owner's permission. Sam's death. A few years pass and Dawn begins to get sick cancer or some other terminal illness. If you need any persuasion, you can read out glowing review here.